Warning: Not a pleasant read for Bengali’s or West Bengal Lovers
Just after the endsems we joined at ISI. I was lucky to get a room in the Guest House. It was due to Prof Bimal Roy, who helped me with the accommodation even though I wasn't working under him. Bless him, for it proved to be a huge help. As it turned out, only the Guest house had Wi-Fi facility and after one month, to my delight, I was moved into an air conditioned room. Not to mention that it was free of charge for me while others, like Anurag and Swati, lived in Hostels and had to pay for the rooms too.
Anyway, this is not what I wanted to talk about. I am writing this post to voice my opinion or rather vent my feelings about the culture and people in Calcutta.
The Traffic -
But that doesn't make life simple for you, trust me. The traffic on the roads is mind numbing. You loose track of time after being stuck in the traffic for more than two hours. After a few days here, whenever we thought about going out to eat or watch a movie, we would think about the traffic and shudder. No place was near or far, they were all separated by a sea of taxis, cars, buses and trams, all issuing great deal of smoke and honking their horns. And when we weighed our trip against all this, it never seemed worth the effort.
And every time I cross a road in Kolkata, I always have a vision of getting hit by a bus. No, seriously! Observing the buses on the roads gives me the impression that the drivers are possessed ! And the road just outside ISI always has a mad rush of buses and trucks. So I have a lot of nightmares about dying on that road.
Contemptuous attitude -
Apart from the laziness, the people here make you feel that you owe them something. It is something about the way they talk to you. Whether it is a sweeper, a shop keeper, taxi driver, guard or anyone. You ask a shopkeeper for something, he will act like you just caused him immense trouble. The attitude that they are the bosses reeks most from the people lowest in the hierarchy. That is why Bengali people make the worst businessmen. I feel they don’t want to really earn more than what they usually get. Two years in Kgp was the reason I was not surprised when I walked out in the afternoon to buy some snacks and found all shutters down. All shops here open late, shut down at lunch and don’t open till late evening. The owners give utmost importance to their comforts. Eating and taking a nap in the afternoon is what matters the most, who wants to make money?
Inside Campus -
But once you make your peace with the fact that there is no Veggies, Sahara or Billoo’s as your escape from the muck they serve in the mess, and the fact that you cannot really go out without the risk of getting stuck in the traffic for an eternity or worse getting hit and dying. When you finally make peace with all this, you can live through it. Meals become a mechanical affair, eating only to assuage the burning feeling at the pit of your stomach.
And life goes on.
Nothing mentionable ever happens inside campus. People with thick eye glasses and clothes that seem to belong to someone else, trudge to the Institute everyday carrying bags and talking animatedly in Bengali. They eat their food on time and disappear by night, after which there is no one on the streets but dogs. The campus is pretty small but green. In the time in which I used to walk from my room to SN gate, in that I can cover the whole ISI campus, twice!
Murphy couldn't have been more right -
Everything that could have gone wrong, went wrong. My laptop crashed. All my back up data on the external disk got lost because, well, that crashed too! On my way to get the hard disk repaired, someone stole my wallet! So after losing two ATM Cards, ID Card, Insurance card etc etc, I thought life couldn't get any worse. So life decided to surprise me. Anurag got admitted twice in Apollo Hospital which wasn't made any easier by the fact that I had to deal with the Bong staff there and take endless rides to the Hospital. Then Swati and Anurag, both thought it would be fun to leave me alone here and left (that might not have been the only reason though ).
The Silver lining (yes, there is always one) -
Now that my stay here is almost over, I am quite relieved. There is no love lost between me and Kolkata now and that makes one thing certain- I wouldn’t come running over to Cal every other weekend, like I used to do earlier.
The so called 'project' -
Almost all the work we did here was just reading up topics, implementing algorithms – self study basically. It was good in a way, as I got to learn a lot of things, which was the reason we wanted to come in the first place, but it was also a bit disappointing. The presentations given by the other students, most of them from ISI, were actually a great test of my patience.
Anyway, after cribbing so much about everything, I must admit that I am glad I took up this subject. I learnt a lot about Algorithms, coding was fun and it gave me confidence that I never knew I could have. But whatever happens, I am never ever going to work anywhere in West Bengal after this, not in this lifetime.
Such an inconvenience in their lives, aren't we?
ReplyDeleteFrankly, kgp shares a lot of the above features to make life as unpleasant as possible and respect home ever the more.
aha! i like the part about swati and annu's other reason :)...i have always been saying something like this would happen :P
ReplyDeleteaha! i like the part about swati and annu :)...i have always been raising this point :P
ReplyDeleteLol! You were really pissed. Not very far from the truth, but when you have lived in Cal your whole life, you learn to love the better things. And miss it when you are in Mumbai :P
ReplyDeleteThat's exactly a photocopy of what i experienced last year in ISI Kolkata. And that's the reason i preferred staying back in kgp rather than extended the last year's project.
ReplyDeleteNicely Written though! :)
Anyone Can Write
oh come on it ain't that bad .. it's just a matter of who you deal with, i too had lived in kgp for 4 years and dreaded the thought of living in kol after i was posted here, but somehow apart from the traffic i just love this city .. well i guess people in south kol are more cosmopolitan .. in fact i have felt much more hostility from the auto drivers and the locals in bangalore, kolkata is quite warm most ways, and 9 times out of 10 the cabbies have gone where i have wanted 'em to go
ReplyDeletemost of the stuff you've written is quite true Shikha, but I must ask of you not to estimate everything about Kolkata merely by your impression of the area around ISI. The average Kolkatan has hardly ever visited that side of the city. :)
ReplyDeleteThat's exactly a photocopy of what i thought, will happen If I did an internship in Cal,so I didn't applied for any in first place... :P
ReplyDeleteThank you for the varied opinion guys. I had forgotten to moderate the comments all along. Was surprised to find so many of them :)
ReplyDelete@Indra and Chirag: I guess you are right. Most of it came out of frustration that had lil to do with the main city.
@Ramesh: Maybe I will gain more perspective if I have to stay in Cal. But as of now, I don't think I'd want to :)
@Arun: I really agree. We are a inconvenience in their lives. And they do nothing to hide the sentiment.
@Abhas: I'll just " :P " you !
@whomsoever it may concern : If you live in a shit-hole for a long enough time, the smell might stop bothering you but the fact is "it still is a shit-hole".
ReplyDeleteAfter reading this post what I feel is some people are just not meant to spend their life in a metro city in general and Kolkata in particular. In fact , the experience narrated is typical of a villager who having spend her/his entire life in a 2 sq km oasis of greenery,freshness and peace finds it extremely difficult to cope up with the mad rush , traffic, population and pollution of a 1750 sq km city. Its no wonder that she/he will lack the basic skills needed to surf a metro city and hence will form an opinion of the entire city by visiting a couple of places bordering on the outskirts of the city.
ReplyDeleteAlso its no wonder that such people will lack the common sense and/or ability to surf the net in advance and form an idea of the city life, people, language, food, commonly used transportation etc. A natural consequence of this mental, physical, pshycological or intellectual handicap is that she/he will fail to negotiate with a taxi driver, will opt for taxi in the first place being oblivious of the metro railway service autos and numerous near empty buses, will fail to spot the most hip-and-happening part of the city, will fail to judge which people will be able to communicate in hindi or english other than bengali and end up getting pissed off altogether.
Well, after having spent one month at Bangalore we could have similarly complained about the kannads who surprisingly dont even understand hindi, the bus conductors who doesnt even know where to get down for IISc or TATA Institute as it is called here, the pathetic non veg food even at IISc, the utterly polluting vehicles, the never ending metro constructions, the mindless and stupid kannad movie posters and every other thing that we have come by. But we and i believe most of the people understand that every large city has its own share of problems and way of life that seems alien to outsiders for the first few days. But if one is willing, these hurdles are not difficult enough to overcome.
PS. I agree with Anurag completely but would like to extend it further. If you stay in a shit hole long enough , the shit hole not only stops bothering you but it starts feeling like heaven and to such an extent that the real heavens that you might occasionally visit , being devoid of all that crap that your shit-hole-like-home-city has to offer, feels like a shit hole. :-)
@hsisahens: Somehow your comment had been marked as spam all this time and it is only by accident that I spotted and published it today.
DeleteLate as it is, here is my reply:
"After reading this post what I feel is some people are just not meant to spend their life in a metro city in general and Kolkata in particular."
I am very happy with the other "metro" cities - Bombay, Delhi, Bangalore, Pune etc. And yes, some people are just not meant to spend their life in *Kolkata* - I couldn't have put it better.
And sorry, I am no villager who has spent her entire life in some magical picturesque land. And that is not what is wrong with Kolkata - its not about how green or peaceful the city is - it is about the mismanaged traffic, old and obsolete infrastructure, the rigid anti-development & growth attitude of the government and people.
"hence will form an opinion of the entire city by visiting a couple of places bordering on the outskirts of the city."
Your presumptuousness is quite annoying - I have been to almost every place there is to visit in the city and I don't think that changes anything I had to say about it.
Also, your condescension has clearly marred the point you tried to make. If you want to debate about pro and cons of Kolkata without emotions clouding your judgement, please do so.
Phrases like "lack the common sense and/or ability to surf the net", "physical, pshycological or intellectual handicap", "fail to spot", "fail to judge", etc make it sound like I am an imbecile and if that is so why did you waste your precious time on my blog.
Or perhaps you are one those hopeless Kolkata romantics who just can take any criticism of the sadly quaint city. Yes, every "large" (Area ratio of Kolkata to Delhi = 1/8) has its own share of problems but any outsider (without bias) would tell you Kolkata has just way too many.
I am sure if I have to live in Kolkata I will eventually overcome these "hurdles" but why do people have to compromise and settle if the city can develop and improve like all the other cities. They might as well live somewhere better.
Good to know you have found your heaven in a shit-hole.
I do not want to the same fate- hence the angry rant.
Ma'am,
ReplyDeleteCan you please tell me, what's the procedure to do internship at ISI, please ?
I'm a 2nd yr CSE student.
@Abhishek:
DeleteI don't know what the official procedure is. I had emailed some professors (working in fields I am interested in) that I wanted to work with them during the summers. You can do the same if you like - just to do not spam the whole of ISI, such mails rarely ever get replies.
At least you GET taxis in Kolkata....In Delhi, you can wait for an hour without getting one... However I agree, taxi-drivers in Kolkata are a bit of a nuisance...... But even then, it's cheaper in Kolkata....... As a matter of fact the autos in Delhi are more expensive than taxis here!
ReplyDeleteI'm assuming you tried talking to Bengalis in Hindi......To be honest, that's not something most Bengalis appreciate at all, so we do tend to be rude whenever someone assumes we know Hindi, it's a form of protest against the dominance of your language over ours and you'll face this in Bangalore and Madras as well..... We're just proud of our language and culture....
A Bengali can't go to Allahabad and assume that everyone knows Bangla either....If he does and is treated rudely by locals, he shouldn't be complaining about how the people of Allahabad refuse to acknowledge the fact that there are people who don't speak Hindi.....The respect has to come from both sides...
And I agree with your depiction of shopkeepers in Kolkata..... Nothing seems to bother them....The customer is always wrong :P